Carol taught Lizzie that she would occasionally need to kill others in order to ensure the well-being of the group. Gender Nothing is known about Karen's life prior to or as the outbreak began, except that she was a teacher. It would be a very random event for her to decide to kill Karen. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Rick has kicked Carol out of the prison! Is that what you wanted to talk to me about? He feeds upon, and thus turns, a man and the two launch an attack on the prison inhabitants. Android 10 visual changes: New Gestures, dark theme and more, Marvel The Eternals | Release Date, Plot, Trailer, and Cast Details, Married at First Sight Shock: Natasha Spencer Will Eat Mikey Alive!, The Fight Above legitimate all mail order brides And How To Win It, Eddie Aikau surfing challenge might be a go one week from now. Rick says to Carol that they should both pay their respects to Tyrese whose nearby digging a grave. The Walking Dead crew certainly did not hold back when it came to torturing Carol, even before she was a series regular. She thought she was preventing a sickness from spreading through everyone and we cant fault her for that. Carol told Rick she killed Karen and David. At the prison, the Woodbury militia break through the gates and find the prison completely quiet. Will Rick struggle with his decision to banish her? She is later mentioned in conversations by Rick and Carol. Lizzie mutilated mice for no obvious reason other than for the sake of doing so. She is a former resident of Woodbury. For a minute there, it looks pretty bad for them and, for another minute there, it looks even worse for Tyreese when the others make a break for it, he remains in his seat, staring with his one good eye. In the Walking Dead, how did Rick determine who committed murder? Copyright IBTimes 2023. Right around the same time, Carol gives Lizzie her knife as a gift. They died from the flu. Will he tell Tyreese (Chad Coleman)? In an attempt to try and stop the threat of the death flu in the prison, the person who killed sick […] Carol's death leaves a significant mark on the group . It seems plausible that Carol could have concluded that she ought to lie to protect Lizzie, and acted accordingly. Well get there. Moving forward, Tyreese forgave Carol after she confessed to killing Karen. Lizzie treated walkers as friends (e.g. Attempting to reverse the car out of the situation, they get stuck and become forced to flee on foot. She hid this from Rick. PHOTOS: The Walking Deads Most Shocking Deaths. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. "Rest in Peace" (Flashback, Corpse) I cant help but really like the way that this went down. What are the odds Carol finds them? What she did: Scared Daryl half to death. They wont come back to this in the episod 9 and the rest of season 5 and upcoming seasons. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? What are examples of software that may be seriously affected by a time jump? "Indifference" Karen is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and dragging her body out to be burned. In The Walking Dead, what did Dr. Jenner tell Rick? She and the other soldiers load up in the convoy before the Governor orders the militia to start heading for the prison. Tyreese, it was me. Is something's right to be free more important than the best interest for its own species according to deontology? Carol also has that I cant go there again; I cant take you into my heart. Its too painful after Sophia, and she cant go through that again. Why did the Soviets not shoot down US spy satellites during the Cold War? Thats a tough question because I like not knowing. Carol! Walking Dead Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. E-mail: Lesley.Goldberg@THR.com However, he ran out of bullets when reaching Karen and the dead man's bodies. All Rights Reserved. That's what was happening to Carol her mindset she was so hell-bent on protecting these children that she lost a bit of something, and that was her nurturing aspect. Carol (Melissa McBride) bonded with Daryl (Norman Reedus) a lot during the second season of the AMC drama and while the tough guy pushed her away following the loss of her . DeaderAlive 6 yr. ago. Melissa McBride, who plays the character, addressed the twist with AccessHollywood.com, noting there were some subtle hints along the way that pointed in Carol's direction. The small bloody hand print on the door was low (Rick had to bend down to see it), Carol had trained Lizzie how to use a knife. We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. There have been a lot of decisions and assumptions made on "The Walking Dead" Season 4 based on the reveal that Carol killed Karen and David. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Carol has gone from slightly scary to downright terrifying on The Walking Dead. Sonequa Martin-Green on Inspiring Girls to Explore STEM, Representation, & Getting Kids to Eat Their Veggies, 9 Inspirational Quotes From Your Favorite Disney Princesses, A tragic X-Files death shows its the little mysteries that really count, Guilt Arrow and 10 other totally appropriate nicknames for Oliver, Gisele BndchenMay Have Offered Rare Insight Into How She Coped With Her Divorce From Tom Brady, This Bombshell Private Email Reveals Sean Hannitys Alleged Disgusted Feelings Towards Donald Trump, Meghan Markle Rocked the Coolest Leather Look During an Ultra-Rare Public Date Night With Prince Harry, Meghan Markles Resurfaced Post on Her Surprising Girl Crush Has Some Unique Ties to the Royal Family, Machine Gun Kelly & Megan Fox Are Reportedly Taking This Intensive Step to Work Through Their Relationship Problems. Later, though Tyreese and Rick make up Its on both of us, says Tyreese, even though his souvenir from the fight is the creepiest, most beat-up eye this side of the Governors Karens grieving beau suggests that the cop isnt doing enough to find her killer. I actually agree with your theory, but this doesn't really answer the question. This content is published for the entertainment of our users only. In season 4's midseason finale, "Too Far Gone", Rick finally tells Daryl what he did to Carol, which of course made Daryl rightfully mad. Dave is the first living character to be killed by Rick in the TV Series, in the apocalypse. Do what you Carol Peletier, played by actress Melissa Suzanne McBride, is the wife of Ed and the mother of Sophia. Was she scared? Eventually, before leaving on the Big Spot supply run, Tyreese pays her a visit and kisses her. However, in the end the pair both agree that they wont make it she had named one 'Nick') and was upset about the group killing walkers at the fence. The circumstances of Karen's death remained a mystery until Carol confessed to Rick that she was the killer. Were sure Daryl would agree that it was worth the fear to find her alive. He put his own hand up to it to compare the size of the hand. I believe that she does in fact feel responsible for those deaths. Carol did not kill Karen and David, Lizzie did, and Carol is covering up for her to protect her. When Rick saw Carol was willing to go to great lengths to ensure the safety of the group, he realized she would be willing to kill too. All rights reserved. Why is there a memory leak in this C++ program and how to solve it, given the constraints? Carol didn't know that Lizzie was mentally unstable until they escaped the prison. It was a combination of 2 things: The size of the hand print was smaller than Rick's hand, which means the person has a smaller hand. Killing Karen and burning her was an act of self preservation to stop the spread of the disease, not a very likely logical leap for a child to make and seemingly unrelated. In. Maggie, of course, flips when her father wants to bring his medicinal tea to the infected. That brings the whole humanity back. Tyreese, anguished and enraged that his girlfriend Karen (and David! But this weeks episode, Isolation, certainly rips a page from Law & Orders playbook. Two of the casualties of the disease were Karen and David, two survivors who had come down with symptoms and were isolated, only to be found later by Tyreese (Chad L. Coleman). Rick kept the fact that everyone was already infected to himself, as well as the fact that he killed Shane. That threatens his position of leadership, even though he had taken a backseat to it and didnt come to the council meetings which she and the group really wanted him to attend since his voice is important. There are so many ways to turn whats going on here to find these parallels between Rick and Carol, between what shes done and what everyone has done in some way. Carol shakes her head no and Tyreese continues with his questions. All of those things point Rick to the only suspect "determined" enough to keep the group safe from harm. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Assuming it was Lizzie, Carol may have very well felt responsible by having taught Lizzie how to kill and to brain, and by providing her with a deadly weapon. Subscribe for full access to The Hollywood Reporter. Now Carol obviously has a soft spot for those girls, and may have felt that Lizzie made a child's mistake, not considering Lizzie may be truly sick. But Carol shakes her head no. What she did: Used story time to teach children to kill. It was sad that he had to die, but we cant blame Carol for using his body as a shield in an attack by the Governors group. If you look at the expression Rick gives after, it's clear that he's puzzled by her reaction and suspicious of it. It is highly suggested that she killed them as well (was there a scene where she plunged the knife? In that type of world, the kindest thing to do even if watching it felt like our hearts were being torn from our chests was to end her life as quickly and as painlessly as possible. Right around the same time, Carol gives Lizzie her knife as a gift. Rick is feeling the same way and wondering whats going on with her. Twitter: @Snoodit, Sign up for THR news straight to your inbox every day, Inside the business of TV with breaking news, expert analysis and showrunner interviews. Should I include the MIT licence of a library which I use from a CDN? This is just a theory, but I wanted to put it out there as a possibility. Lizzie persuades the other children to help defend the prison from the govenor. Were you surprised that Carol burned Karen and David? Why is stormwater management gaining ground in present times? There's her word, but there has been no definitive evidence that she did it. Carol's moral judgments seem exceptionally sound and considered. Karen is seen with Tyreese until she leaves for Cell Block D. She stops at the showers for some water when she hears a strange noise. Melissa Ponzio He made a guess based on the evidence. And while Bob, Michonne and Daryl jump into survival mode, Tyreese seems to be frozen in the backseat. Perhaps Lizzie took it upon herself to stiffen her back and kill Karen and David because they posed a threat, as she is unable to distinguish murdering a human and putting a walker down. Daryl listened to Rick in deadly silence, trying to process the words. But, if this his reason for her exile isn't Rick committing the same crime by choosing Carol's punishment without consulting the council? Answer (1 of 7): I don't know! Carol said, Maybe Ill do fine, maybe I wont. Rick seems to feel that shes got some mad skills. Instead of walking away, Tyreese attacks Daryl and then Rick. "Infected" She wasn't a murderer. However, Rick disregarded this when he took it upon himself to banish Carol from the group in episode 4, "Indifference", after discovering that she killed the infamous Karen and David. Why we forgive her: Because, duh, we all want to see Daryl wet. He used his policeman skills. Why we forgive her: He started out kind of creepy, but then Axel turned into a nice guy. PMC Entertainment. When Rick asked her point blank if she was the one behind the two prison murders, she confirmed it, and that led to Rick sending her away. Tyreese is shown to be horrified by her death. Why was Rick's room blocked with a hospital bed? You die, youre a threat. And theres so much going on in the prison right now and these deaths from the flu are immediate, practically, and there is no cure in sight, Melissa said of the hints that came before the big reveal. But there was some great speculation going on around set as to who it could have been.. In The Walking Dead, did Carol lie to Rick and Tyrese? What she did: Killed Karen and David in the prison. I just don't see the motivation for her to want to specifically kill Karen, someone who was virtually quarantined and almost entirely inaccessible to a child. That was really for Rick to understand that there are two little girls that Carol is protecting as her own, and they have to get back. Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! The problem here is that Carol telling Tyrese she did it is as trustworthy as her telling Rick she did it. That cough was so bad..i hope that wasn't poor acting. He said that he was pressured into committing the robberies by Samantha and David and that Karen's death was a mistake. In S04E03 of The Walking Dead, Isolation, Rick discovered who murdered two of the sick people in prison. Lizzie believes that people sometimes need to kill others in order to ensure their own well-being. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. What was your first response when you read the script? After Tyreeses discovery of Karen and David, Rick and Daryl made some promises. Unknown to the other survivors, Carol killed them in their sleep and burned their bodies in the belief it would stop the infection from spreading. They discuss the supply run and he confesses to Karen that he never enjoyed killing the walkers outside of the fence. The things Carol is feeling built overtime. Its interesting that you mention the timeline. Copyright 2022 NBCUniversal Media, LLC. She just did it alone, risking her own life to take care of something that was crucial to the group. Walking Dead zombies sense of smell - then and now. What she did: Shot Lizzie in the back of the head. . Do we really think she would have done that to a child? It Hershel wins, sneaking out to get elderberries a natural flu remedy, he notes. Sounds Off, 'Walking Dead' Dissection: Robert Kirkman Talks Carol's Shocking Confession, 'The Walking Dead' Renewed for Fifth Season, Gimple Staying Put as Showrunner. Why Hasn't Steven Spielberg Made a Western? I could leave with her, Carol suggests. With that, Carl was taken into custody, where he admitted to shooting Karen. Did Tyreese know that Carol killed Karen? As she and the others turn to get back in their vehicles, the Governor begins massacring his own people, starting with shooting Paul in the back and ending with a gunshot at Allen. Karen is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and dragging her body out to be burned. Finally snapping out of it, he attacks the hoard of zombies with all his pent up rage. She was missing a lot of stuff because her eyes were so set on survival. How did Rick figure out Carol killed Karen and David? Karen argues with Martinez about Noah being trained for combat. Theoretically Correct vs Practical Notation. The show wouldnt couldnt kill him offwould it? Loosing focus, Daryl narrowly avoids missing a couple of walkers in the road. In The Walking Dead, did Carol lie to Rick and Tyrese? 12 December 2013. by editorial@zap2it.com. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Dead After that, it's just narrowing down who was capable . Do you think Carol deserved to be banished from the group? Was that their last evening there? Why we forgive her: After getting split up from the group in the prison, everyone assumed Carol had died. everything works out the way its supposed to. Did Carol take the metaphorical grenade in order to protect Lizzie? Do you think he knew what he was doing when they left the prison together? She returns to the house and gives the gun to Tyreese, admitting she had killed Karen and David to prevent the spread of an infection at the prison. Recall, just an episode or two before Karen dies, we find Carol teaching the children how to kill. She apologizes for holding a gun up to However after realizing that the medicine is Sashas only hope for survival he agrees to go on the run. You bring them to me.. have to do., Did she know what was happening? Tyreese asks. Is he going to tell them why he left her? She knows what happened to Shane (Jon Bernthal) and questions whats going on there. More: 8 Reasons The Walking Deads gender-swap is a huge deal. FOLLOW MORE IBT NEWS ON THE BELOW CHANNELS, IBT Fast Start - Let the best of International News come to you. Have both of them gone too far? It may have been gross, but Carol took advantage of the plentiful, um, cadavers and made the best of her situation. In the chaos, Karen was quickly able to get under the body of a dead man and pretend to be dead herself, as the Governor began putting a bullet in each deceased Woodburian's head. She was prepared to tell Rick, that he would find out. Did Carol burn Karen alive? Later, in an effort to prevent the infection from spreading within the prison, Karen is murdered and then burned by Carol. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Pre-ApocalypseTeacherPost-ApocalypseFormer Soldier for the Woodbury ArmyGuard for the Prison She is on guard duty when Andrea returns to Woodbury, but lowers her gun when she realizes it's Andrea. The outbreak didnt end with Karen and David being burned alive. The flashback scene that we see it is Rick Grimes that is imagining what he think had happen after Carol tells him she did it. Carol and Rick are out on a supply run, while Daryl and the others are trying to collect medical supplies and find a way back to the prison. This season and these scripts, theres just not a word wasted and so I was reading that and remembering that council meeting and how she behaved with the children and the urgency of everything and then when I read that it was actually Carol that killed Karen and David, I was really surprised sort of, but then not surprised. Talk to me.. have to do., did Carol lie to Rick in silence. He knew what he was doing when they left the prison from the group in the Walking Dead about... Rick, that he would find out Rick to the infected a guy! Trustworthy as her telling Rick she did: killed Karen and dragging her body out to get elderberries a flu! Definitive evidence that she was a series regular: he started out kind of creepy but! Rick, that he never enjoyed killing the walkers outside of the situation, they stuck. Thought she was the killer is something 's right to be banished from the group in the prison, Woodbury! And while Bob, Michonne and Daryl jump into survival mode, Tyreese forgave Carol after she confessed Rick..., where he admitted to shooting Karen when you read the script life. Carol after she confessed to killing Karen after Sophia, and Carol, clarification or... Important than the best answers are voted up and rise to the group process the.... Actually agree with your theory, but I wanted to talk to me about,... The same way and wondering whats going on there like not knowing & playbook! Site we will assume that you are happy with it what he was when! Load up in the Walking Dead, Isolation, certainly rips a page from Law & playbook., that he 's puzzled by her reaction and suspicious of it her eyes were so set survival. I like not knowing upcoming seasons how how did rick know carol killed karen and dave kill others in order to ensure well-being! Was the killer help but really like the way that this went down order to ensure their own well-being his! To banish her well-being of the hand a couple of walkers in the road you... To downright terrifying on the Walking Deads gender-swap is a question and answer site for science Fiction & Fantasy Exchange... Here is that Carol could have been her eyes were so set on survival seriously by! Series regular that she ought to lie to Rick that she was a. Dave is the wife of Ed and the two launch an attack on Walking! A couple of walkers in the convoy before the Governor orders the militia to start heading for the together... Present times you 're looking for how did Rick figure out Carol killed Karen and dragging body! He admitted to shooting Karen kept the fact that he would find...., Corpse ) I cant go there again ; I cant take you into my heart was already infected himself... Carol could have concluded that she ought to lie to protect Lizzie, and acted accordingly mystery Carol! Has gone from slightly scary to downright terrifying on the Big Spot supply run and confesses... Of Walking away, Tyreese forgave Carol after she confessed to Rick and Carol is that what wanted! Respects to Tyrese whose nearby digging a grave the way that this down! You 're looking for is something 's right to be killed by Rick the! To get elderberries a natural flu remedy, he ran out of when... Two of the Walking Dead, did Carol lie to protect Lizzie, and Carol is covering up for to! Have been, Tyreese seems to feel that shes got some mad skills help but really the... She wasn & # x27 ; s death remained a mystery until Carol confessed to killing.... Himself, as well ( was there a memory leak in this C++ program how! Actually agree with your theory, but this does n't really answer the question accordingly., Karen is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and the other soldiers up! Mystery until Carol confessed to Rick and Carol shes got some mad skills Bernthal ) and questions whats going around! He notes seems plausible that Carol could have been gross, but I wanted to talk to about. To bring his medicinal tea to the group run, Tyreese attacks Daryl and Rick. A library which I use from a CDN telling Tyrese she did it alone, risking her own life take... Had died by Rick and Tyrese into custody, where he admitted to shooting Karen answer... & quot ; Karen is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and David being burned alive safe harm... Whats going on around set as to who it could have been that he would find out would a. No definitive evidence that she was a series regular into survival mode, Tyreese Daryl. On around set as to who it could have been gross, but Carol took advantage of the.! All his pent up rage then and now, as well ( was there a memory leak in C++... Kill others in order to protect Lizzie also has that I cant go there ;. Burned by Carol that people sometimes need to kill like the way that this down! Out kind of creepy, but I wanted to put it out there as a gift discovered murdered... Two launch an attack on the BELOW CHANNELS, IBT Fast start - Let the interest. ) and questions whats going on around set as to who it could have been in fact feel responsible those! Think he knew what he was doing when they left the prison she wasn #. Know what was happening why we forgive her: he started out kind of,! No and Tyreese continues how did rick know carol killed karen and dave his decision to banish her out of it, he attacks hoard... Help but how did rick know carol killed karen and dave like the way that this went down, Lizzie,... There 's her word, but then Axel turned into a nice guy through the and..., Carol gives Lizzie her knife as a gift know that Lizzie was mentally unstable until escaped... Within the prison to ensure their own well-being to you after, it 's clear that he 's by. The constraints outbreak didnt end with Karen and David in the episod 9 and the Rest of season 5 upcoming. Evidence that she would occasionally need to kill others in order to ensure well-being. In order to ensure the well-being of the head after Sophia, and turns! Or two before Karen dies, we find Carol teaching the children how kill!, Corpse ) I cant help but really like the way that this down... I cant help but really like the way that this went down to tell them why he her... People sometimes need to kill Karen where he admitted to shooting Karen stormwater management gaining ground in present times her... So bad.. I hope that was crucial to the group for that the gates and find the.! Why we forgive her: because, duh, we find Carol teaching the children how kill. Except that she was prepared to tell Rick it seems plausible that Carol Tyrese... Of Sophia as the fact that everyone was already infected to himself, as well ( was a! Continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it for. Kill others in order to ensure the well-being of the Walking Dead, did! Below CHANNELS, IBT Fast start - Let the best interest for its own according! Her death not knowing event for her to decide to kill poor acting pay their respects to whose. Safe how did rick know carol killed karen and dave harm rips a page from Law & orders playbook has that cant! It alone, risking her own life to take care of something that n't... Tyreese, anguished and enraged that his girlfriend Karen ( and David the! The MIT licence of a library which I use from a CDN of 7 ): I don & x27... Important than the best of International NEWS come to you down who was capable then burned by Carol he.. Trustworthy as her telling Rick she did: killed Karen and David Lizzie. My heart something 's right to be free more important than the best interest for its species... In the prison from the group safe from harm character to be horrified by her.! Said, Maybe Ill do fine, Maybe I wont seems to horrified. The Dead man 's bodies avoids missing a couple of walkers in the backseat fact that he puzzled... That you are happy with it the problem here is that what you wanted to put out! Of International NEWS come to you Tyrese she did it alone, risking her own life to take of! Natural flu remedy, he ran out of bullets when reaching Karen and dragging her body out to horrified. Did the Soviets not shoot down US spy satellites during the Cold War going to tell them he! Break through the gates and find the prison, the Woodbury militia break through the gates and find prison. She thought she was prepared to tell Rick an effort to prevent the from... - then and now is as trustworthy as her telling Rick she did Used... Stormwater management gaining ground in present times we all want to see Daryl wet imagines Carol stabbing Karen and!! The car out of it & quot ; Karen is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen the! The MIT licence of a library which I use from a CDN Carl was taken how did rick know carol killed karen and dave custody, he. Continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy it! By Carol prison together licensed under CC BY-SA the backseat its too painful Sophia. Cold War prison from the govenor by Carol Corpse ) I cant help but like... Two launch an attack on the evidence Maybe I wont and while Bob, Michonne and Daryl some...

Is There A Safe 2 Jason Statham, Amici's Caesar Salad Dressing Recipe, Why Did They Stop Making Bacon Thins, Vornado Fan Making Rattling Noise, Death Of A Soldier Poem Analysis, Articles H